28 May 2018

Your Weekly Market Focus
 
Europe Slowdown Continues

Author: Richard Jerram, Chief Economist, Bank of Singapore, Member of OCBC Wealth Panel

Flash PMIs for May point to a continued slowdown in the Eurozone economy. However, business sentiment remains at healthy levels, suggesting fluctuations in the pace of growth, but not a threat to the underlying expansion.

25may2018-money-mondayTo put the current situation in context, the overall PMI of 54.1 is a touch stronger than the 53.5 average of 2015-2016, when GDP growth was running at 1.9%.

We cannot see a fundamental reason for a further meaningful slowdown in Eurozone growth. Government budgets are in balance and the pressure for austerity has faded. The benefits of the structural reform of recent years are filtering through. Monetary policy transmission is improving as stronger banks are better able to boost lending. It looks like the softer patch since the start of this year partly reflects temporary factors such as strikes and weather, and is partly just a correction from exceptionally strong levels.

The ECB is likely to remain focused on the outlook for inflation, rather than short-term fluctuations in growth. As with other regions, Europe is finding inflation relatively unresponsive to tighter capacity conditions.

It looks like the ECB will follow the same playbook as the Fed. This means continuing with asset purchases until well after they seem to be necessary, phasing them out carefully, and then allowing the dust to settle before starting to raise interest rates.

In practical terms, that means that the ECB winds up asset purchases by the end of this year and then raises interest rates in 2Q 2019, or perhaps a little later if inflation still lags. As in the US, any temporary signs of economic weakness are a signal to err on the side of caution, and delay rate hikes. Other developed economies seem to be following the same path, with a soft patch of data pushing back the next rate hike from the UK, Canada and Australia.

Italy does not seem to be a big risk to this outlook. Chaos, inaction and, ultimately, more elections still seems like the most probable outcome, in which case the impact on European growth, policy or financial markets should be limited.

Despite its recent troubles, Italy is still the third biggest Eurozone member, accounting for 15% of the region. It is nine times the size of Greece. The unlikely coalition of two populist parties, from the right and left, appears to have abandoned some of its previous anti-Euro positions, but there are still plans for a major easing of fiscal policy. Considering Italy’s weak public finances, legal barriers and the instability of the government it looks unlikely that they can implement radical change, but there is understandable market concern.

Of course plans for fiscal stimulus are not a problem for short-term growth. The issue is more of an existential one, in the event that Italy reneges on its side of the bargain – fiscal prudence and reform – that was the counterpart to ECB President Draghi’s “whatever it takes” commitment.

 
OCBC MoneyMonday™